The Foundation of Buddhism
The Buddha’s Response to Vedic Religion


The “Historical” Buddha
Siddhattha Gotama
(
c. 566-486 BCE)


The early texts clearly see the conception and the other key events of Gotama’s life, such as his birth, enlightenment, first sermon, and death, as events of cosmic importance; for at all of them they say that light spread throughout the world and the earth shook.  The Nidanakatha relates that at the time of the conception, Mahamaya, his mother, dreamt that she was transported to the Himalayas where a being in the form of an auspicious white elephant entered her right side.  On recounting this dream to her husband, Suddhodana, he had it interpreted by sixty-four Brahmins.  They explained that it indicated that his wife had conceived a son with a great destiny ahead of him.  Either he would stay at home with his father and go on to become a Cakkavatti, a universal emperor—which the Suttas say that he had been six times in previous lives—or he would become a wandering ascetic and become a great religious teach, a Buddha. [An Introduction to Buddhism, 16]

The Great Renunciation

One day, the young prince, longing to see the outside world, went out for a chariot ride through the capital city.  There, for the first time, he saw a decrepit old man.  Shocked, he asked his charioteer about the man’s condition; the charioteer replied that such is the destiny of all human beings.  The prince turned back to the palace and brooded in melancholy, taking no relish in the gaiety around him.  On a second ride, he saw his first diseased man and reflected that people are foolish to revel under the constant shadow of illness.  On the third trip, he saw his first corpse.  Dismayed, he marveled that people could live heedlessly, forgetting the certainty of death....While meditating on the truth of suffering, he saw a religious mendicant and made up his mind to leave the household life, for only as a renunciate would he have the chance to follow rigorously the Path of mental training to see if it led to the impeccable happiness—beyond the reach of aging, illness, and death—that he sought. [Richard H. Robinson and Willard L. Johnson, The Buddhist Religion: A Historical Introduction, Fourth Edition (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1997), p. 12; cf. An Introduction to Buddhism, 17-18]

The new mendicant, then 29 years old, went first to an ascetic teacher named Arada Kalama, who taught a form of meditation leading to the “attainment of the state of nothingness.”  Gautma practiced the method and quickly attained the goal....He then studied under another ascetic leader, Udraka Ramaputra, who taught the way to a higher state, the “attainment of neither perception nor non-perception.”  Gautama mastered this state and was proclaimed a teacher, but abandoned the method because it was inadequate for attaining his goal of “disenchantment, dispassion, cessation, tranquillity, superknowledge, Awakening, and nirvana.” [BR, 13; cf. ITB, 18-19]

Leaving Udraka Ramaputra and the path of formless absorptions, the Bodhisattva then went eastward to Uruvela near Bodhgaya, where he found a pleasant spot and settled down to try the path of austerities.  He practiced holding his breath in order to induce trances and was not deterred by the resulting violent headaches.  Fasting, he came as close as he could to eating nothing at all, becoming utterly emaciated....Then, seeing that severe mortification had not led to liberating knowledge, and having exhausted the various forms of ascetic practice current in his day, he tried to think of another way.... [BR, 13-4; cf. ITB, 19]

As the full moon rose over the river before him, the Bodhisattva focused on his in-and-out breathing and ascended the four stages of dhyana.  The first stage is a meditative absorption produced by detaching from sensual thoughts and unskillful attitudes.  The mind attains a state of unity while evaluating the object to which it consciously directs its thoughts, giving rise to a sense of rapture and ease born of seclusion.  The second stage is an absorption free from the activity of evaluation and directed thought.  There is singleness of mind and internal assurance, in addition to rapture and ease born of composure.  The third stage—dispassionate rather than rapturous—is mindful and fully aware, with a feeling of bodily ease.  The fourth stage is a state of pure equanimity and mindfulness, free of elation and sorrow, pleasure and pain. [BR, 15; cf. ITB, 21-22]


Then in the third watch of the night, he declared his intention to achieve direct perception of the destruction of evil inclinations, and disciplining himself and persevering, he meditated on the dharmas that are conducive to enlightenment....
.
.
...And he truly realized:  “This is the Noble Truth of Suffering; this is the Origination of Suffering; this is the Cessation of Suffering; this is the Noble Truth of the Way leading to the Cessation of Suffering.”  Knowing that and seeing that, he was then released from thoughts inclined to sensual desire, he was released from thoughts inclined to rebirth, he was released from thoughts inclined to ignorance.  And released, he had a realization of his liberation:  “Destroyed is my birth; consumed is my striving; done is what had to be done; I will not be born into another existence!”  Thus the Blessed One attained the highest enlightenment. [John S. Strong, The Experience of Buddhism, Second Edition (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, 2002), p. 17; cf. ITB, 22]

The Four Noble Truths


.

I. Life is Suffering/Unsatisfactory
dukkha
This, O bhikkhus, is the Noble Truth of suffering (dukkha):  Birth is suffering, aging is suffering, sickness is suffering, death is suffering, sorrow, and lamentation, pain, grief, and despair are suffering, association with the unloved or unpleasant condition is suffering, separation from the beloved or pleasant condition is suffering, not to get what one wants is suffering.  In brief, the five aggregates of attachment are suffering. [IR, 117]
  • Was the Buddha a pessimist?  Why not try to maximize pleasure and minimize pain?
.
II. “Desire” is the Cause of Suffering

This, O bhikkhus, is the Noble Truth of the origin of suffering:  It is craving which produces rebirth, bound up with pleasure and greed.  It finds delight in this and that, in other words, craving for sense pleasures, craving for existence or becoming and craving for nonexistence or self-annihilation. [IR, 117]
  • Do you agree that desire is the cause of suffering? Why or why not?
.
.
III. Suffering Will Cease
When Desires Cease
This, O bhikkhus, is the Noble Truth of the cessation of suffering:  It is the complete cessation of suffering; giving up, renouncing, relinquishing, detaching from craving. [IR, 117]

So who’s the pessimest now?

  • Does the elimination of desire inevitably lead to the extinction of suffering?
  • If suffering can be eliminated, then why do we fail to pursue this as a serious goal?
.

IV. The Way to Realize this State
The Noble Eightfold Path


.
This, O bhikkhus, is the noble Truth of the path leading to the cessation of suffering.  It is simply the Noble Eightfold Path, namely:  Right understanding, right thought, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right awareness, and right concentration. [IR, 117]
.

.
.
.